The Showdown: Choice Home Warranty vs First American Home Warranty

Image of the author

By Ben Carter

Updated August 1, 2025
Blog Section Image
In-Depth Look

Is Your HVAC System Covered? The Warranty Deep Dive You’ll Actually Use

Here’s the thing—warranty talk usually gets buried under jargon until something breaks in July and you’re staring down a surprise bill. Let’s fix that. I’ll quickly map what’s covered, what’s not, and how to keep coverage intact after hvac-system-installation, so you can make confident, wallet-safe choices.

The quick refresher: three warranty buckets

Think of HVAC protection in layers. First, the manufacturer’s parts warranty. That’s the one tied to the brand name on your condenser, furnace, or heat pump. Second, the installer’s workmanship or labor warranty—coverage for how everything was put together. Third, optional extended labor plans that turn big repair bills into smaller service calls. The clock usually starts on the hvac-system-installation date, so that date matters.

Believe it or not, most warranty headaches come from mixing up those layers. Parts may be free under manufacturer terms, but the labor to diagnose and replace? That’s often separate. We’ll untangle it so you’re never guessing at the kitchen table with a quote in hand.

What most manufacturers actually cover

Most major brands cover parts for up to 10 years if you register on time; skip registration and it often defaults to around 5 years. Covered parts usually include compressors, coils, heat exchangers, control boards, and internal fans. Accessories (like thermostats or UV lights) may have shorter terms. If your hvac-system-installation includes matched, brand-approved components, you usually get the best coverage.

Heads up: parts coverage means the component itself is provided at no cost if it fails from a manufacturing defect. It doesn’t automatically include the technician’s time, refrigerant recovery, or shipping—those fall into the “not covered” pile more often than not.

The fine print that bites (what’s not covered)

Here’s where people get burned. Warranties commonly exclude labor, diagnostic time, refrigerant, filters, belts, and shipping or freight. They also exclude issues caused by improper sizing, code upgrades, power surges, flood or storm damage, and lack of maintenance. If you DIY or use an unlicensed installer, you can void manufacturer coverage—even if the part itself looks “defective.” So if hvac-system-installation didn’t follow the book, parts support can evaporate fast.

One more curveball: mismatched equipment (like pairing a new high-SEER condenser with an old coil that isn’t approved) can reduce efficiency and coverage. The paperwork cares about “properly matched” more than you’d think.

Installer warranties and labor coverage

A good local installer stands behind labor for at least a year, often two. Some offer extended labor coverage for 5–10 years through third-party plans. That means if a part fails under the manufacturer warranty, your labor is largely handled too—huge relief. Ask what’s included: trip charges, after-hours rates, refrigerant, and diagnostic fees can sneak in. If your hvac-system-installation came through a big-box retailer, clarify whether the store or the subcontractor handles labor claims. You want one number to call when it’s 95°F and not cooling.

Quick gut-check: if a bid is way cheaper because it skips labor coverage, compare the savings to one out-of-warranty compressor swap. The math flips fast.

Registration, transfer, and proof (the boring stuff that saves you)

Most brands require registration within 30–60 days for full terms. Do it once, correctly. Keep a single folder (paper or digital) with your paid invoice, install date, permit, model and serial numbers, and the installer’s license and phone. Selling the home? Many warranties transfer once within 60–90 days for a small fee. A clean paper trail tied to your hvac-system-installation can turn a tense service call into a quick part swap.

Pro move: snap photos of the nameplates and store them with your registration confirmation. You’ll thank yourself later.

Keep your coverage: maintenance that actually matters

Most warranties expect routine maintenance. That usually means annual tune-ups, changing filters every 1–3 months (or cleaning mini-split screens), and keeping coils and drains clean. Log each visit. If a claim pops up, you can show you did your part. If your hvac-system-installation included a new thermostat, keep firmware updated and settings sane—overly aggressive set-backs can ice coils and raise eyebrows.

Oh, and don’t mix refrigerants or top off blindly. That can void coverage faster than you can say “shorted compressor.”

Red flags during install and how to file a claim

If an installer won’t pull a permit, dodges load calculations, or refuses to list model and serials on the invoice, I’d walk. Those details protect you later. For a warranty claim, start with your installer, not the manufacturer. They’ll diagnose, confirm the failed part, and process the parts claim. Ask for the diagnostic notes and the part number they’re replacing. Keep the old part until the claim is approved. If your hvac-system-installation is recent, your labor warranty might pick up most costs; otherwise, ask for a line-item breakdown before green-lighting anything.

Tiny tip: document noises, error codes, and when the issue happens. That saves time and sometimes a second trip fee.

Bottom line (and a tiny, friendly nudge)

You want three things dialed: timely registration, clear labor coverage, and proof of proper hvac-system-installation. Do that and you’ll avoid 90% of warranty drama. If you’re comparing brands or installers right now, I put my favorite value picks and notes in Consumer's Best product reviews—short, honest, and built to save you from surprise repair bills later. When you’re ready, take a peek and choose with confidence.

Frequently Asked Questions

An HVAC installation warranty (from the contractor) typically covers workmanship and labor—things like proper sizing, brazing, charging, wiring, and startup. If something was installed incorrectly and fails within the stated period (often 1–2 years), the contractor fixes it. Manufacturer warranties, by contrast, usually cover parts only. Pairing both is the key to stress-free hvac-system-installation outcomes.

Featured Reviews

Carousel Logo image
Home Warranty Plans

Select Home Warranty Reviews: Protecting Your Home & Budget

Our expert Select Home Warranty review covers plans, pricing, coverage, and customer feedback. See if Select Home Warranty is the right choice for protecting your home in 2025.

Carousel Logo image
Home Warranty Plans

A Smart Homeowner's Best Secret?

Our expert Liberty Home Guard reviews cover plans, pricing, customer service, and more. Find out if Liberty Home Guard is the right choice for your home protection needs.

Carousel Logo image
Home Warranty Plans

What Do They Really Cover?

Explore our in-depth Home Warranty of America (HWA) review. We cover plans, pricing, customer service, and help you decide if HWA is the right home warranty for your needs.

Carousel Logo image
Home Warranty Plans

The Ultimate Homeowner Money Hack?

Explore in-depth Choice Home Warranty reviews. Discover if their home protection plans, coverage options, and pricing offer the best value for your needs.

Carousel Logo image
Home Warranty Plans

The Home Service Club Reviews: Expert Analysis & Consumer Insights

Explore comprehensive The Home Service Club reviews. Discover plans, pricing, coverage, and customer feedback to see if this home warranty is right for you.

Carousel Logo image
Portable White Noise Machines

Homedics Portable White Noise Machine Review 2025 | Consumers Best

Struggling with sleep while traveling? Our expert review covers the Homedics portable white noise machine's features, performance, and value. Find out if it's the right choice for you.

Carousel Logo image
Joint-Health & Pain-Relief Devices

Does HoMedics Stuff Actually Work?

Discover the best HoMedics foot massager for your needs. Our expert review covers features, benefits, and who it's best for. Find relief today!

Carousel Logo image
Home Security & Smart Locks

Wyze Review: Smart Home Simplicity on a Budget

Explore comprehensive Wyze reviews covering their range of smart home devices, cameras, and security solutions. Discover if Wyze offers the best value for your needs.

Carousel Logo image
Home Security & Smart Locks

Is Keyless Entry Really Better?

Explore our comprehensive Vivint home security review. Discover features, pros, cons, and pricing to see if Vivint Smart Home is the ideal security solution for you.

Carousel Logo image
Home Security & Smart Locks

How Secure Is Your Home?

Explore our in-depth Lockly smart lock review. Discover its advanced security features, keyless convenience, and if it's the right choice for your smart home.

Carousel Logo image
Smart Thermostats

Finally, a Smart Electric Thermostat?

Explore our expert Honeywell Home T5 Smart Thermostat review. Discover its features, performance, and if it's the right smart thermostat for your home.

Carousel Logo image
Home Security & Smart Locks

Lockly Smart Lock Review: Secure & Innovative Home Access

Explore our in-depth Lockly smart lock review. Discover its advanced security features, keyless convenience, and if it's the right choice for your smart home.

Carousel Logo image
Home Security Systems

The Best DIY Home Security?

Explore comprehensive Wyze reviews covering their range of smart home devices, cameras, and security solutions. Discover if Wyze offers the best value for your needs.

Carousel Logo image
Smart Fitness Equipment

Tempo Fit Review: The Smart Home Gym Revolutionizing Workouts

Our expert Tempo fit review covers features, performance, and who it's best for. Discover if the Tempo smart home gym is your ideal fitness solution.

Carousel Logo image
Tri-Band Wi-Fi Mesh Systems

eero Pro 6E Review: The Ultimate Whole-Home Mesh WiFi System?

Is the eero Pro 6E whole home mesh system worth it? Our expert review covers its speed, coverage, Wi-Fi 6E performance, and value for demanding households.

Carousel Logo image
In-Home Health-Monitoring Devices

Comprehensive Health Insights at Home

Our expert Withings Body Scan review explores its advanced segmental body composition, 6-lead ECG, nerve health, and vascular age features. Is it worth the investment?

Carousel Logo image
Smart Fitness Equipment

A Gym-Quality Workout At Home?

Our expert NordicTrack 1750 review explores its powerful motor, iFIT workouts, incline/decline features, and overall value for serious home fitness enthusiasts.

Carousel Logo image
Home Security & Smart Locks

Is Home Security This Simple?

Our expert SimpliSafe Outdoor Camera review covers features, performance, pros & cons. Find out if this security camera meets your needs. Consumers Best.

The use of brand names and/or any mention or listing of specific commercial products or services herein is solely for educational purposes and does not imply endorsement by OLM Inc (DBA Consumer's Best) or our partners, nor discrimination against similar brands, products or services not mentioned.

Advertising Disclosure: OLM Inc (DBA Consumer's Best) is a free online resource that operates an advertising-supported comparison service. We may receive monetary compensation when a sponsored product or service is displayed on our site or when you click on certain links contained herein. Such compensation, together with our ranking process which uses advanced AI to analyze public data and the geographic availability of a product, can influence the placement, prominence, and order in which products appear within our listings. Although we endeavor to present a broad spectrum of financial and credit-related offerings, Consumer's Best does not purport to include every product or service available in the marketplace. All products are presented without warranty. When evaluating offers, please review the financial institution's Terms and Conditions. The information, including pricing, that appears on this site is subject to change at any time.

© 2025 OLM Inc 100 S Commons Ste 102, Pittsburgh, PA 15212